Skip to main content
  • Ben & Jay's Pizzeria logo top - Homepage
    Ben & Jay's Pizzeria logo scroll - Homepage
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Order from CHICKASHA location
    • SKYTAB
    • DOORDASH
    • SLICE
  • Order from LAWTON location
    • SKYTAB
    • DOORDASH
    • SLICE
  • Go to top
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Ben & Jay's Pizzeria logo top - HomepageBen & Jay's Pizzeria logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Order from CHICKASHA location
    • SKYTAB
    • DOORDASH
    • SLICE
  • Order from LAWTON location
    • SKYTAB
    • DOORDASH
    • SLICE

Our Menu

  • Menu

Appetizers

Wings

House Buffalo, Mango Habanero, BBQ, Sweet Chili, Garlic Parmesan, Lemon Pepper, Hot Honey

6 Count $8 (up to 1 Flavor; 1 Dipping Cup)
12 Count $15 (up to 2 Flavors; 2 Dipping Cups)
24 Count $25 (up to 3 Flavors; 3 Dipping Cups)

Thousand Fries

$10.00
Covered with cheese, thousand island dressing, grilled onions.

Super Fries

$12.00
Covered with a mozzarella/cheddar blend, bacon, green onions, sour cream or ranch.

Basket of Mozzarella Sticks

$10.00

Basket of Fried Pickles

$10.00

Basket of Breadsticks

$5.00

Basket of Tater Kegs

$10.00

Basket of Pretzels

$6.00

Hot Honey Cheese Curds

$9.00

Onion Rings

$10.00

Meatballs

$9.00
5 meatballs, house marinara, mozzarella, ricotta; served with a breadstick.

Spinach Artichoke Dip

$12.00

Salads

Add Chicken $2/$4
House Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Italian, French, Caesar, House Balsamic or House Red Wine Vinaigrette

Salad Bar

$9.00

Chef Salad

Half $7 / Full $13 • Lettuce, tomato, bell pepper, boiled egg, ham, turkey, cheddar cheese.

Ben & Jay's Salad

Half $7 / Full $11 • Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, parmesan cheese, croutons.

Cobb Salad

Half $9 / Full $14 • Lettuce, tomato, chicken, bacon, egg, avocado, cheddar cheese.

House Salad

$6.00

Grilled Chicken Salad

Half $9 / Full $14 • Lettuce, spinach, grilled chicken, mozzarella, tomato, avocado.

Greek Salad

Half $7 / Full $11 • Lettuce, feta, green olives, tomato, onion.

Antipasto Salad

Half $9 / Full $14 • Lettuce, tomato, artichokes, green olives, onion, pepperoni, salami, mozzarella, feta.

Sammyz

Served with your choice of Fries, Tots or A Bag of Chips.
Add Veggies for $3 or Salad Bar for $3

Gyro

$12.00
Lamb meat, onions, lettuce, tomato, house-made tzatziki sauce.

Meatball Sub

$13.00
Meatballs, house marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese, mayo.

Philly Cheesesteak

$14.00
Steak, onion, bell pepper, mozzarella cheese, mayo.

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$14.00
Chicken, bacon, ranch, cheddar blend, lettuce, tomato.

Chicken Parm Sammy

$14.00
Crispy chicken, house marinara sauce, mayo, mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese.

Italian Sub

$14.00
Salami, Candian bacon, pepperoni, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo.

Chopped Cheese

$14.00
Beef, grilled onions, melted American cheese, mayo, mustard, lettuce, tomato.

Chicken Wrap

$11.00
Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, corn, black beans.

Chalupa

$13.00
Bacon, ham, turkey, cheddar cheese, avocado, jalapeno, mayo.

BLT

$11.00
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.

Club Sammy

$12.00
Ham, turkey, bacon, cheese, tomato, lettuce, mayo.

Pastas

Served with a Breadstick.

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$12.00
1/2 order $9.00

Spaghetti & Meatsauce

$11.00
1/2 order $8.00

Chicken Alfredo

$15.00
1/2 order $10.00

Shrimp Alfredo

$16.00
1/2 order $11.00

Chicken Parm

$15.00
1/2 order $10.00

Burgers

That’s a Burger

$11.00
Onion, lettuce, tomato, pickles.

Bacon Cheeseburger

$14.00
Bacon, cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato, pickles.

Cheeseburger

$12.00
Cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato, pickles.

Patty Melt

$14.00
Two 4 oz patties with Swiss cheese blend, pickles, mustard, mayo, grilled onions on Texas toast.

Our Pizzas

Gluten-free and Keto-friendly options available.

10" Personal Pizza

$9.00

14" Large Pizza

$14.00
Feeds up to 3 • Add Topping $1.75

18" Extra Large Pizza

$17.00
Feeds up to 5 • Add Topping $2.25

28" XXXL Pizza

Feeds up to 8-12 • Add Topping

Meat/Cheese Toppings

Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Italian Sausage, Beef, Salami, Chicken, Bacon, Meatballs, Pork Sausage, Anchovies Feta, Ricotta, Mozzarella, Cheddar

Veggie Toppings

Tomato, Mushrooms, Bell Peppers, Onions, Black Olives, Green Olives, Spinach, Banana Peppers, Jalapenos (Pickled or Fresh), Artichokes, Green Chili Peppers, Pineapple, Sauteed Garlic Cloves, Artichokes

Other Toppings

Hot Honey, Balsamic Glaze, Pesto, Garlic Oil

Pizza Fixin's

Served with your choice of Marinara, Ranch, or Jalapeno Ranch or Garlic Butter.

Calzone

$10.00
Up to 3 toppings; with mozzarella and ricotta.

Stromboli

$11.00
Up to 3 toppings; filled with house marinara and mozzarella.

Pizza Rolls

$8.00
Four per order; pepperoni and mozzarella cheese.

Cheesy Bread

$8.00

Specialty Pizza

The Mr. Meaty

10" $12 | 14" $21 | 18" $27 • Canadian bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, beef.

Hawaiian

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $24 • Canadian bacon, bacon, pineapple.

Veggie

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $24 • Spinach, feta, tomato, onion, black olives, seasoned mushrooms, banana peppers.

Supreme

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $26 • Pepperoni, Italian sausage, onions, bell peppers, black olives, seasoned mushrooms.

When in Rome

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $26 • Spinach, chicken, bacon, drizzle of alfredo sauce.

The Italian

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $26 • Alfredo sauce, salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage, banana peppers.

BBQ Chicken

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $26 • BBQ sauce, chicken, red onions, mozzarella/cheddar blend.

Our Pizza Margherita

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $24 • House marinara, sliced roma tomatoes, basil oil drizzle, sprinkle of sea salt.

Jalapeno Popper

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $26 • Cream cheese, fresh jalapeno, bacon, cheddar/mozzarella blend.

Cheeseburger Pizza

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $24 • Mustard/mayo sauce, American/mozzarella blend, beef, onions, lettuce, tomato, pickle.

(Kickin’) Chicken Bacon Ranch

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $24 • Garlic parmesan sauce, chicken, bacon, cheddar blend; house ranch & green onions post-bake (fresh jalapenos & buffalo sauce for the kick!)

Pigger Is Better

10" $12 | 14" $21 | 18" $27 • Salami, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, bacon, Italian sausage, pork sausage.

Gyro My Hero

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $26 • House-made tzatziki sauce, lamb meat, feta, onion, tomato, lettuce.

Dill Pickle Pizza

10" $12 | 14" $18 | 18" $24 • Salami, sliced dill pickles, dill weed, cheddar/mozzarella blend.

Santa Fe

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $24 • Pepperoni, bacon, green chili peppers.

Garlic-O-Holic

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $24 • Garlic oil, mushrooms, onions, sautéed garlic cloves, green bell peppers, sea salt sprinkle.

Ricotta Bee Kidding Me

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $25 • House-made marinara, pepperoni, ricotta cheese, basil, hot honey.

BLT Pizza

10" $12 | 14" $18 | 18" $24 • Mayo, bacon, tomato, lettuce.

Chicken Pesto

10" $12 | 14" $20 | 18" $26 • Olive oil, spinach, chicken, feta, sliced tomato, green olives, pesto drizzle.

Mexican Pizza

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $25 • Pepperoni, chicken, fresh jalapenos, tomato, onions, green bell peppers, cheddar/mozzarella blend.

The Artie Party Pizza

10" $12 | 14" $19 | 18" $25 • Cream cheese base, spinach, artichoke, ricotta, tomato, balsamic glaze.

Kids’ Menu

Each kid's meal includes a soft drink.
Ages 10 and under!

7" Cheese Pizza

$7.00
Add toppings for $0.50

Grilled Cheese & Fries

$7.00

Kids Alfredo

$7.00
Add chicken for $1

Chicken Fingers & Fries

$7.00

Corndog & Fries

$7.00

Kids Spaghetti

$7.00
Comes with 1 meatball & breadstick.

Desserts

Seasonal Cakes

$7.00

Tiramisu

$7.00

Cannolis

$6.00/2

Raspberry Cheesecake Chimichanga

$6.00/3

10" Dessert Pizza

$10.00
Seasonal fruit filling.

Zeppole / Fazoli Donuts

$4.00
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs